Headline

Local Perspectives on the Two Sessions | Giving Students a Voice in School Uniform Selection

Category: Special Feature

Release Date: 2022-01-24

Summary: Recently, during the Two Sessions, the Central Committee of the Revolutionary Committee of the Chinese Kuomintang submitted a proposal to the National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, stating that some school uniforms are unattractive and unpopular among students, and recommending improvements to their aesthetic appeal and comfort. School uniforms originated in Europe and were initially imported; they first appeared in China after the Xinhai Revolution. The practice of requiring students to wear uniform clothing was originally intended to prevent social comparisons over attire and to foster an egalitarian educational environment. Over time, with societal development, school uniforms have taken on additional meanings and functions, becoming an important component of school culture.

  Recently, during the Two Sessions, the Central Committee of the Revolutionary Committee of the Chinese Kuomintang submitted a proposal to the National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, stating that some school uniforms are unattractive and unpopular among students, and recommending improvements to their aesthetic appeal and comfort.
  School uniforms originated in Europe as an imported concept and first appeared in China after the Xinhai Revolution. The practice of requiring students to wear uniform attire was initially intended to prevent social comparisons over clothing among children and to foster an equitable educational environment. Over time, with societal development, school uniforms have taken on additional meanings and functions, becoming an integral part of school culture.
  Since the launch of reform and opening-up, while spurring rapid economic development, China has also witnessed a profound emancipation of thought and ideology. School uniforms have gradually been adopted across all levels and types of schools, becoming a standard part of students’ attire. The rise of school uniforms has not only led to increasing diversity in styles and fabrics, but also to greater alignment with the needs of students from different socioeconomic backgrounds.
  Although school uniforms bear the name “school,” they are worn by students, and it stands to reason that students should have a certain degree of say in choosing their uniforms. In practice, however, there is often an overemphasis on uniformity, with the school authorities firmly holding the dominant role. What kind of uniform to wear reflects a school’s ethos and spirit, and it is all the more important to take into account the general affordability of such attire. Still, there is nothing inherently wrong with the school retaining a leading role in this matter.
  In order to promote school uniforms, some schools have shifted their focus away from such considerations as “whether students like them” and “whether the prices are reasonable,” and instead brazenly incorporated “wearing school uniforms” into routine disciplinary evaluations—conducting uniform checks upon entering campus and in classrooms—thereby using institutional mandates to compel every student to order and wear them, completely disregarding students’ feelings.
  It is precisely because the school takes the lead in selecting uniforms—and compounded by other influencing factors—that uniform manufacturers naturally pay little attention to students’ preferences and instead focus their efforts on design and development, needing only to satisfy the school’s requirements. Perhaps it is precisely for this reason that some school uniforms are unattractive in style, poor in quality, uniformly identical across schools, and even that “toxic uniforms” have emerged.
  These uniform-related issues may seem trivial, but they actually harm students. They not only undermine the development of students’ sense of collective identity and their ability to appreciate and experience beauty, but also thwart parents’ desire to reduce their financial burden. Moreover, such problems can even cause physical harm to students, thereby impeding their healthy development.
  Students are the future of the nation. Any factor that hinders their development, no matter how minor, is of paramount importance. Therefore, when it comes to the “school uniform issue,” we must accord it the highest priority, systematically dismantle the “local protectionism” that impedes school uniforms from keeping pace with the times, respect students’ right to voice their opinions, and harness market principles so that students can wear uniforms that reflect their youth and cultural identity.
  To ensure that students have a voice in deciding what kind of school uniform to wear, schools should, prior to ordering, extensively solicit student input—whether by inviting students to participate in the design process or by offering a variety of styles for students to choose from—and then, through a process of “seeking broad consensus while accommodating minor differences,” steadily build agreement on key aspects such as the uniform’s style, fabric, and price.
  At the same time, during the procurement of school uniforms, schools should create opportunities for students to actively participate in such processes as “selecting the manufacturer” and “negotiating prices.” This not only fosters students’ awareness of democracy and civic engagement but also brings “sensitive issues” into the open, thereby effectively rooting out potential corruption.
  Paying attention to school uniforms means paying attention to students’ healthy development. It is undoubtedly a sound strategy to promptly address the problems and shortcomings in such uniforms and to give students an appropriate degree of voice in the process. Although resolving these issues cannot be accomplished overnight, once the first step is taken, overcoming the challenges will inevitably follow sooner or later.
  Although school uniforms are closely tied to a school’s culture and educational image, at the end of the day they remain a matter for students themselves, and therefore must be handled with the utmost care. Students should rightly be given an appropriate voice in deciding what they wear.

Keywords: Local Perspectives on the Two Sessions | Giving Students a Voice in School Uniform Selection

Related Information

Industry