Headline

Smart School Uniforms’ Positioning Feature Sparks Controversy; Experts Say Students’ Personal Dignity Must Be Respected

Category: Media

Release Date: 2022-01-24

Summary: Facial-recognition attendance tracking, GPS location services, cashless payments… Recently, a smart school uniform has been reported to be undergoing trial use in more than ten primary and secondary schools across southwestern China, sparking widespread discussion and attention. Facial-recognition attendance tracking, GPS location services, cashless payments… Recently, a smart school uniform has been reported to be undergoing trial use in more than ten primary and secondary schools across southwestern China, sparking widespread discussion and attention.

  Facial-recognition attendance tracking, GPS location services, cashless payments… Recently, a smart school uniform has been reported to be undergoing trial use in more than ten primary and secondary schools across China’s southwestern region, sparking widespread discussion and attention.
  According to the manufacturer, by embedding chips in the shoulders on both sides of the school uniform, this smart uniform integrates contactless attendance tracking, academic administration, and home–school communication, with the goal of building a smart campus.
  On the other hand, concerns have also arisen regarding “increasing monitoring restrictions that infringe on students’ privacy” and “how the collected sensitive data will be used.”
  In response, Li Daguo, the legal representative of the company that developed these smart school uniforms, recently told The Paper that whether to use the smart uniforms is up to parents and schools. At present, there is no “round-the-clock monitoring” of students; the positioning feature is only offered to meet the needs of a small number of parents and has not been rolled out across the board. Moreover, data security is subject to multiple layers of oversight by public security authorities and other relevant agencies.
  Regarding the upgraded features currently under development for smart school uniforms—such as “detecting students dozing off in class” and “allowing parents to check their children’s on-campus spending via mobile phones”—Professor Liu Yongmou of the School of Philosophy at Renmin University of China told The Paper that minors, too, possess independent personal dignity, and that their right to privacy must be fully respected when smart school uniforms are used.
  Liu Yongmou argues that comprehensive surveillance is fundamentally at odds with the educational ideal of fostering well-rounded citizens who possess self-respect, self-love, self-reliance, self-discipline, and self-confidence; it is a simplistic, heavy-handed, and lazy approach whose drawbacks in education far outweigh its benefits. Accordingly, he contends that, amid the ongoing debate over smart school uniforms, legal and regulatory safeguards are urgently needed. “When schools, parents, and manufacturers risk infringing upon the privacy rights of minors, government, the state, and society must step in to establish clearer regulations governing the production and use of smart school uniforms, thereby protecting young people.”
  Smart School Uniforms That Monitor Student Entry and Exit and Provide Location Tracking Spark Controversy
  In September 2017, students at the No. 11 Middle School in Renhuai City, Guizhou Province, became among the first to try out this smart school uniform.
  According to the school’s official website, it is a boarding junior high school located in the urban–rural fringe, with nearly 1,000 students. Zhou Dakun, the school’s principal, told The Paper that currently 200 fourth-grade students are using this smart school uniform system.
  This “smart school uniform,” developed by a technology company in Guizhou Province, looks and feels just like a regular school uniform. According to the manufacturer, each uniform is equipped with an embedded chip that stores the student’s name, class, and facial profile. The design integrates RFID, infrared sensing, fingerprint recognition, and facial recognition technologies, and is supported by complementary devices such as access-control sensors and a dedicated mobile app.
  For example, when individuals pass through the facial-recognition turnstiles at school or dormitory entrances, the system automatically captures and verifies their facial data. At the same time, the guard station’s display screen shows the corresponding student’s profile photo, while the system simultaneously records and pushes to parents’ and teachers’ mobile apps the student’s precise daily entry and exit times, along with a 20-second real-time video feed.
  According to the vendor’s design, this system can monitor whether students are skipping school, arriving late, or staying out overnight without requiring individual identification. If the system fails to recognize a person or detects a student sneaking out, it will issue an audio alert to prompt security personnel to tighten supervision.
  Among the features of this smart school uniform, the “GPS-enabled real-time tracking of students’ whereabouts” has sparked the most public debate.
  In response, Li Daguo, the legal representative and general manager of the company that developed the school uniform, told The Paper that the GPS tracker—whose primary functions include route tracking and one-button emergency alerts—has not yet been integrated into the clothing itself. “We have incorporated this feature into the school badge as a paid custom service; we will not be promoting the positioning function to schools. A small number of parents do have such needs—for instance, when they want to track their child’s location outside of school—and will purchase and install the device separately.”
  How can we prevent the misuse of student and parent data collected by smart school uniforms?
  Li Daguo stated that the collected data is categorized into two types: for instance, leave requests and academic performance records are retained in the background for the long term, whereas video data such as students’ entry and exit from school gates is typically overwritten after one to three months under normal circumstances.
  On the issue of data security, Li Daguo stated that parents must undergo real-name authentication before they can access their children’s information, and no third parties are permitted to view it. Local public security authorities maintain strict oversight over companies that handle such data. Furthermore, no single technician is authorized to log into the company’s backend system; multiple passwords must be entered simultaneously to gain access. Importantly, this data is intended solely for use by students and parents.
  Li Daguo stated that the company established itself in Guiyang High-tech Industrial Development Zone, the “China Big Data Industry Base,” in 2015 and launched this smart school uniform in July 2017.
  On the company’s official website, The Paper found that in April and June 2018, officials from the Nanning District Education Bureau of Guiyang City, along with several primary school principals, visited the company to inspect its “smart school uniform” project.
  However, when The Paper contacted the Education Bureaus of Renhuai City in Zunyi and Nanming District in Guiyang, staff members stated that they were unaware of any schools under their jurisdiction using smart school uniforms, as the selection of school uniforms is an institutional decision and falls outside the bureaus’ purview.
  In response, Li Daguo stated that the primary consumers of school uniforms are parents, and the uniforms are not funded by the education bureau. However, the education authorities have indeed expressed interest in the project. “If a school adopts this product, we will provide the local education authority with a management interface to enable data sharing, thereby strengthening the authority’s oversight of schools.”
  “The use of smart school uniforms has been approved by both the school and parents. In most cases, the decision on whether to implement them is made by the parent committee. These days, parents’ top priority is likely their children’s safety. Even if some students are reluctant to use certain features, they can only discuss it with their own parents. We merely provide the service; how it is ultimately used is up to the parents and the school to decide,” said Li Daguo.
  According to Li Daguo, the smart school uniform will soon be upgraded with additional features, including an automatic alarm that sounds when the system detects a student dozing off in class; cashless payment within the school campus via fingerprint, finger-vein, and facial recognition; real-time monitoring of students’ spending habits, allowing parents to check their child’s daily expenditures on their mobile devices and set daily spending limits; and continuous tracking of students’ physical condition, with alerts sent to teachers and parents if significant fluctuations are detected. In addition, the uniform will record daily data such as activity levels and heart rate, enabling analysis of the student’s growth, development, and physical fitness.
  According to the company’s official website, currently 11 primary and secondary schools are using this school uniform, with 10 located in Guizhou Province and 1 in Guangxi. Li Daguo stated that more than 20,000 students are already wearing it on a daily basis.
  Expert: Students’ right to privacy and personal dignity must be fully taken into account.
  According to publicly available information, the smart school uniform sector remains largely uncharted territory internationally; however, China already has more than one manufacturer specializing in such products.
  In the era of the Internet of Everything, no unified consensus has yet been reached on standards and regulations for information security. Since smart school uniforms have come into the public eye, questions about some of their functions have also emerged. On the one hand, there is growing concern: Do these devices infringe on students’ right to privacy? Could they have a negative impact on children’s mental health? On the other hand, how can the sensitive data collected by the platform be protected, and who should be responsible for oversight?
  On February 3, Professor Liu Yongmou of the School of Philosophy at Renmin University of China told The Paper that privacy information on minors collected by smart school-uniform manufacturers is all too easily leaked to commercial entities, rather than being used solely for educational purposes. Stricter legal and regulatory measures are urgently needed to prevent such breaches.
  On the issue of data protection, Yu Chao, an attorney at Jingheng Law Firm, also believes that legislation is more effective than third-party oversight itself, as regulatory agencies themselves may also leak personal information.
  He stated that the most effective way to deter unlawful conduct is to increase the costs of breaking the law. When violations of citizens’ privacy can even result in criminal penalties, offenders will carefully weigh the potential consequences of their actions.
  As for minors, whether parents’ increased access to their personal information through smart devices constitutes an invasion of privacy or a legitimate form of guardianship is a matter worthy of discussion.
  In response to this issue, Liu Yongmou stated that the Law of the People’s Republic of China on the Protection of Minors explicitly stipulates the guiding principle of “respecting the personal dignity of minors.” In the context of smart school uniforms, the protection of minors’ right to privacy must be given full consideration. Minors, too, possess independent personal dignity. Schools and guardians alike bear not only educational responsibilities but also the duty to safeguard the privacy of those under their care from infringement—particularly from being violated in the name of education.
  However, he also points out that, within the existing ethical tradition, Chinese parents tend to act as “proxies” for their children in various matters, a practice that contrasts with the approach in Europe and the United States. That said, Chinese ethics does not advocate that parents should have the authority to decide every single aspect of their children’s lives; in particular, middle-school students already enjoy greater ethical autonomy. Therefore, on issues such as smart school uniforms, Liu Yongmou argues that, as the primary stakeholders, students’ right to be heard must not be deprived. “There is no doubt that both parental custody and minors’ right to privacy have clear limits; parental custody cannot be used to override a minor’s right to privacy. Of course, where exactly these boundaries lie requires careful, real-world deliberation.”
  “I firmly oppose parents’ unbounded intrusion into their children’s lives,” says Dai Yingpin, Director of the Institute for Mental Health Management at Wuhan University (Shenzhen), echoing Liu Yongmou’s view. She adds, “Children have the right to make their own choices; they should not be expected to live solely according to their parents’ wishes. When children lose their autonomy, their room for growth shrinks, their creativity is stifled, and they find it increasingly difficult to handle matters on their own.”
  Dai Yingpin points out that, from a mental-health perspective, the most significant issue in parent–child relationships within Chinese families is the blurring of boundaries. Commercial products tend to prioritize pleasing paying customers. Smart school uniforms, while making life easier for parents and granting them greater authority, can also easily lead to overreaction. The pervasive influence of information technology and big data often creates a form of power that exerts subtle yet profound control over those who are immersed in it. Children are not prisoners; especially during adolescence, parents should avoid exercising control in ways that directly empower them to impose their subjective judgments and excessive interference in their children’s lives, as this can trigger rebellious behavior.
  She also expresses skepticism about customized location-tracking features: “Even if it’s your own child, is it really reasonable to offer location-monitoring services simply by paying a fee?” In the view of attorney Yu Chao, this is a matter of balancing the protection of minors’ safety with their right to privacy. He points out that, in certain special circumstances, trade-offs must be made. “For example, when a child goes missing, it becomes clear that some degree of privacy must be sacrificed.”
  “The issue of children’s personal dignity is something we simply never took into account when we were innovating our products,” said Li Daguo. “This time, after hearing some differing voices and seeing certain comments, we will certainly engage in self-reflection.”

 

1

Keywords: Smart School Uniforms’ Positioning Feature Sparks Controversy; Experts Say Students’ Personal Dignity Must Be Respected

Related Information

Industry